What constitutes a reasonable accommodation is one of the most complex aspects of jurisprudence under the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA). Even within this already complicated issue, the reasonable accommodation of transfer to a new job position has likely generated the most controversy. While the law specifically identifies transfer to a new position as a potentially reasonable accommodation to an employee with a disability, several prominent court decisions have further hedged when this type of accommodation is available.
It is clear from the statute that a position must already be vacant in order to be available as a reasonable accommodation, but is an employer required to give you preferential treatment in bidding for that position? Our courts have provided some guidance:
- In US Airways v. Barnett, the Court held that reassignment to a vacant position is not a reasonable accommodation if it requires an employer to violate the rules of a bona fide seniority system.
- The United States courts of appeal are currently split on whether an employee with a disability must receive preferential reassignment as a reasonable accommodation in the absence of a formal and bona fide seniority system. Some circuits follow the rule that employers must give preferential consideration, while others follow the rule that an employee must only be allowed to compete for the position. The Supreme Court had granted certiorari to a case that would have settled the issue, Huber v. Wal-Mart Stores, but the parties settled and the case was dismissed.
The uncertainty of the law in this area can give an experienced disability discrimination lawyer a great deal of room to argue your case. If you have been denied a transfer that would have allowed you to keep your job in spite of your disability, it may be worth your while to speak to an attorney. Call us at 800-807-2209 for a free consultation.
- Gender Inequality Targets Workplace Bonuses for Female Employees - January 23, 2023
- California Sexual Assault Law Gives Adult Sexual Assault Survivors Second Chance for Justice - December 21, 2022
- Should Salaried Employees Get Overtime Pay? - December 15, 2022
- Are Nannies Protected Against Sexual Harassment at Work? - November 18, 2022
- Sexual Harassment Runs Rampant in the Hospitality Industry - October 26, 2022
- 7 Employment Discrimination Claims Starting as Microaggressions - October 6, 2022
- Sexual Harassment Attacks Hedge Fund Employees - September 23, 2022
- Working Moms: What Are Your Rights at Work? - August 12, 2022
- 8 Payday Rules Your Employer May Be Breaking - August 2, 2022
- The Effects the Gender Pay Gap has on Women - July 20, 2022