# Sexual Orientation Discrimination After Zarda - Derek Smith Law Group

[Schedule a Callback](/free-consultation/)     [![Derek Smith Law Group](https://discriminationandsexualharassmentlawyers.com/app/themes/discriminationandsexualharassmentlawyers/resources/inc/images/Derek-Smith-Law-PLLC-logo-new.svg)](https://discriminationandsexualharassmentlawyers.com/)   [![Call 800-807-2209](/app/uploads/2024/06/phone-call8.png) Free Consultation 800-807-2209](tel:800-807-2209)

---

[![Sexual Orientation Discrimination](/app/themes/discriminationandsexualharassmentlawyers/resources/inc/images/cat-icon.svg) Sexual Orientation Discrimination](https://discriminationandsexualharassmentlawyers.com/category/sexual-orientation-discrimination/)

# Sexual Orientation Discrimination After Zarda

[Derek Smith Law Group](https://discriminationandsexualharassmentlawyers.com) / Sexual Orientation Discrimination After Zarda

- [![Derek Smith](/app/uploads/2015/12/Derek-T.-Smith.png) Derek Smith](https://discriminationandsexualharassmentlawyers.com/author/derek-smith/) October 22, 2018 2 min. read

Share this post[![facebook](/app/themes/discriminationandsexualharassmentlawyers/resources/inc/images/s-facebook.svg)Facebook](https://www.facebook.com/sharer/sharer.php?u=https%3A%2F%2Fdiscriminationandsexualharassmentlawyers.com%2Fsexual-orientation-discrimination-after-zarda%2F)[![X](/app/themes/discriminationandsexualharassmentlawyers/resources/inc/images/s-twitter.svg)Twitter](https://twitter.com/intent/tweet?text=Sexual%20Orientation%20Discrimination%20After%20Zarda&url=https%3A%2F%2Fdiscriminationandsexualharassmentlawyers.com%2Fsexual-orientation-discrimination-after-zarda%2F&via=spotblue)[![linkedin](/app/themes/discriminationandsexualharassmentlawyers/resources/inc/images/s-linkedIn.svg)LinkedIn](https://www.linkedin.com/shareArticle?mini=true&url=https%3A%2F%2Fdiscriminationandsexualharassmentlawyers.com%2Fsexual-orientation-discrimination-after-zarda%2F&title=Sexual%20Orientation%20Discrimination%20After%20Zarda)[![pinterest](/app/themes/discriminationandsexualharassmentlawyers/resources/inc/images/s-pinterest.svg)Pinterest](https://pinterest.com/pin/create/button/?url=https%3A%2F%2Fdiscriminationandsexualharassmentlawyers.com%2Fsexual-orientation-discrimination-after-zarda%2F&media=&description=Sexual%20Orientation%20Discrimination%20After%20Zarda)[![email](/app/themes/discriminationandsexualharassmentlawyers/resources/inc/images/s-email.svg)Email](mailto:?subject=I wanted you to see this site&body=Check out this site https%3A%2F%2Fdiscriminationandsexualharassmentlawyers.com%2Fsexual-orientation-discrimination-after-zarda%2F)

The question of whether sexual orientation is covered under Title VII has been brought up again in the U.S. District Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit. Recently, the court reversed and remanded a 2016 decision in the matter of *Cargian v. Breitling USA.*The case arose when Breitling employee Fredrick Cargian, who is gay, sued the watch manufacturer for allegedly terminating his employment because of his [sexual orientation](https://discriminationandsexualharassmentlawyers.com/employment-law/sexual-orientation-discrimination/).

Cargian claims that after the company got a new president in 2010, the atmosphere became that of a “boys club” — from which Cargian was excluded. Cargian’s further claims that over the course of two years, the Breitling management team continuously changed the conditions of his employment, from sales goals to territories, which affected his overall sales numbers and performance. Eventually, Cargian says he was replaced by someone else and terminated in 2013. Carigan filed a lawsuit in 2015, claiming discrimination on the basis of sexual orientation under Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964. In September of 2016, U.S. District Court Judge Daniels of the Southern District granted summary judgement in favor of Brietling, reasoning that sexual orientation was not a recognized protected class under Title VII.

Judge Daniels could not foresee the shift in sexual orientation discrimination law that occurred in February of 2018. In the matter of *Zarda v. Altitude Express, Inc.,*the Second Circuit found that the scope of Title VII can be expanded to protect employees from discrimination on the basis of sexual orientation. The Court reasoned “prohibitions must go beyond the principal evil to cover reasonably comparable evils.” In other words, sexual orientation can be considered an actionable subset of sex discrimination because it is impossible for an employer to discriminate against an employee on the basis of their sexual orientation without taking sex into account. Based on the law’s language, if the adverse employment action is motivated by sex, based on the Court’s analysis, it is prohibited under Title VII.

Cases like Carigan’s against Breitling have major ramifications for the way Title VII is interpreted. The Second Circuit’s decision in Zarda overruled case law established by Simonton v. Runyon, 232 F. 3d 33, 35 (2d Cir. 2000) and Dawson v. Bumble v. Bumble, 398 F.3d 211, 217-23 (2d Cir. 2005) that reasoned “discrimination based upon sexual orientation is not currently actionable under Title VII.”  Federal Circuit courts are currently split on the issue and the Supreme Court has been asked to take up this issue and their ruling will have a major impact on employment protections under Title VII.

If you have been subjected to sexual discrimination in the workplace, such conduct may be unlawful. The [New York City sexual harassment](https://discriminationandsexualharassmentlawyers.com/employment-law/sexual-harassment/new-york-city/) and [discrimination](https://discriminationandsexualharassmentlawyers.com/employment-law/employment-discrimination/new-york-city/) attorneys at the Derek Smith Law Group, PLLC have years of experience litigating claims of sexual harassment and discrimination. With offices in New York, Miami, and Philadelphia, the Derek Smith Law Group has received millions of dollars on behalf of our clients who are the victims of discrimination. If you feel you have been subject to unlawful discrimination at work, please give our experienced attorneys a call, toll-free at 1-877-469-5297, for your free consultation.

Free Case Review       Recent Posts

- [Derek Smith Law Group Rebuts Derulo’s “False” Narrative, Asserts Emaza Dilan Gibson’s NY Lawsuit is Active](https://discriminationandsexualharassmentlawyers.com/derek-smith-law-group-rebuts-derulos-false-narrative-asserts-emaza-dilan-gibsons-ny-lawsuit-is-active/) ![date icon](/app/uploads/2015/12/date_icon_d.png) December 17, 2025

- [Derek Smith Law Group PLLC Files Lawsuit Alleging Racial Discrimination and Assault Against Highland Hospital](https://discriminationandsexualharassmentlawyers.com/derek-smith-law-group-pllc-files-lawsuit-alleging-racial-discrimination-and-assault-against-highland-hospital/) ![date icon](/app/uploads/2015/12/date_icon_d.png) November 3, 2025

- [Jason Derulo and Atlantic Records Accused of Sexual Harassment and Retaliation in Lawsuit Filed by Derek Smith Law Group](https://discriminationandsexualharassmentlawyers.com/jason-derulo-and-atlantic-records-accused-of-sexual-harassment/) ![date icon](/app/uploads/2015/12/date_icon_d.png) October 8, 2025

- [Sexual Harassment vs. Sexual Assault: Know the Difference and Protect Your Rights at Work](https://discriminationandsexualharassmentlawyers.com/sexual-harassment-vs-sexual-assault/) ![date icon](/app/uploads/2015/12/date_icon_d.png) August 14, 2025

- [Sexually Harassed or Assaulted by a Billionaire or Multi-Millionaire?](https://discriminationandsexualharassmentlawyers.com/sexual-harassment-sexual-assault-by-billionaires-millionaires/) ![date icon](/app/uploads/2015/12/date_icon_d.png) July 29, 2025

Our Verdicts

### [$15 Million Verdict](https://discriminationandsexualharassmentlawyers.com/verdicts/15-million-verdict-secured-by-derek-smith-law-group-in-child-sexual-abuse-case/)

15 Million Verdict Secured by Derek Smith Law Group in Child Sexual Abuse Case          Last Edited: May 27th, 2025

About Derek Smith

Derek T. Smith, Esq., is the founding attorney of the Derek Smith Law Group, with over 30 years of experience fighting for employee rights. He has secured millions in verdicts and settlements for victims of sexual harassment, workplace discrimination, and retaliation. With offices in New York City, Philadelphia, Miami, and Los Angeles, Derek represents clients nationwide in high-stakes employment and civil rights cases.

[View all posts by Derek Smith](https://discriminationandsexualharassmentlawyers.com/author/derek-smith/) | [Website](https://discriminationandsexualharassmentlawyers.com/)

![Stand Up Against Workplace Discrimination](https://discriminationandsexualharassmentlawyers.com/app/uploads/2025/05/derek-team1.jpg)

## Stand Up Against Workplace Discrimination

Get a Free Case Evaluation – No Fees Unless We Win for You!

Newsletter

Subscribe for Legal Insights and Updates from Derek Smith Law Group

[mc4wp_form id=14304]    Follow Us On

- [![Facebook - Derek Smith Law Group](/app/themes/discriminationandsexualharassmentlawyers/resources/inc/images/s-facebook.svg)](https://www.facebook.com/New.York.City.Employment.Lawyer)
- [![Twitter - Derek Smith Law Group](/app/themes/discriminationandsexualharassmentlawyers/resources/inc/images/s-twitter.svg)](https://twitter.com/dereksmithlaw)
- [![LinkedIn - Derek Smith Law Group](/app/themes/discriminationandsexualharassmentlawyers/resources/inc/images/s-linkedIn.svg)](https://www.linkedin.com/company/derek-smith-law-group-pllc?trk=extra_biz_viewers_viewed)
- [![Instagram - Derek Smith Law Group](/app/uploads/2015/12/instagram5.png)](https://www.instagram.com/dereksmithlawgroup_/)
- [![Pinterest - Derek Smith Law Group](/app/uploads/2015/12/pinterest.png)](https://www.pinterest.com/derektsmithlawgroup/)
- [![YouTube - Derek Smith Law Group](/app/uploads/2015/12/youtube-symbol.png)](https://www.youtube.com/@dereksmithlawgrouppllc)

Our Office Locations    [New York Office](https://discriminationandsexualharassmentlawyers.com/new-york-city/)   The Nelson Tower,
450 7th Avenue, 30th Floor
New York, 10123   [(212) 587-0760](tel:2125870760)  [Map and Direction](https://maps.app.goo.gl/upBDU5BG2QNkPqSz9)    [New Jersey Office](https://discriminationandsexualharassmentlawyers.com/new-jersey/)   60 Washington Street,
Suite #101B,
Morristown, NJ 07960   [(973) 388-8625](tel:9733888625)  [Map and Direction](https://www.google.com/maps/search/?api=1&query=Derek%20Smith%20Law%20Group%2C%20PLLC%2C%2060%20Washington%20St%20Suite%20101B%2C%20Morristown%2C%20NJ%2007960)    [Philadelphia Office](https://discriminationandsexualharassmentlawyers.com/philadelphia/)   1628 Pine Street
Philadelphia, PA 19103   [(215) 391-4790](tel:2153914790)  [Map and Direction](https://maps.app.goo.gl/YpmK3VLmGniXaijP7)    [Miami Office](https://discriminationandsexualharassmentlawyers.com/miami/)   520 Brickell Key
Dr STE O301
Miami, FL 33131   [(305) 946-1884](tel:3059461884)  [Map and Direction](https://maps.app.goo.gl/Rys6pdrb8tFHbjzn7)    [Los Angeles Office](https://discriminationandsexualharassmentlawyers.com/los-angeles/)   US Bank Tower,
633 West 5th Street, Suite 3250
Los Angeles, CA 90071   [(310) 602-6050](tel:3106026050)  [Map and Direction](https://maps.app.goo.gl/WVNHGwwAXWz2rWQSA)    [San Francisco Office](https://discriminationandsexualharassmentlawyers.com/san-francisco/)   601 Montgomery St.,
Suite 312,
San Francisco, CA 94111   [415-915-4322](tel:4159154322)  [Map and Direction](https://www.google.com/maps/search/?api=1&query=Derek%20Smith%20Law%20Group%2C%20PLLC%2C%20601%20Montgomery%20St%20%23312%2C%20San%20Francisco%2C%20CA%2094111)    [San Diego Office](https://discriminationandsexualharassmentlawyers.com/san-diego/)   350 10th Avenue,
Suite 1000,
San Diego, CA 92101   [800-807-2209](tel:8008072209)  [Map and Direction](https://www.google.com/maps/search/?api=1&query=350%2010th%20Ave%20Suite%201000%2C%20San%20Diego%2C%20CA%2092101)    [Washington DC Office](https://discriminationandsexualharassmentlawyers.com/washington-dc/)   1500 K Street,
2nd Floor,
Washington, DC, 20005   [(202) 938-1794](tel:2029381794)  [Map and Direction](https://www.google.com/maps/search/?api=1&query=1500%20K%20St%20NW%202nd%20Floor%2C%20Washington%2C%20DC%2020005)         We are a *top-rated sexual harassment and employment litigation law firm* with an unmatched record representing survivors.

- [Home](https://discriminationandsexualharassmentlawyers.com/)
- [Firm Overview](https://discriminationandsexualharassmentlawyers.com/firm-overview/)
- [Our Team](https://discriminationandsexualharassmentlawyers.com/attorneys/)
- [Sexual Harassment](https://discriminationandsexualharassmentlawyers.com/employment-law/sexual-harassment/)
- [Employment Discrimination](https://discriminationandsexualharassmentlawyers.com/employment-law/)
- [Other Practice Areas](https://discriminationandsexualharassmentlawyers.com/practice-areas/)
- [Our Verdicts](https://discriminationandsexualharassmentlawyers.com/verdicts/)
- [Testimonials](https://discriminationandsexualharassmentlawyers.com/testimonials/)
- [Blog](https://discriminationandsexualharassmentlawyers.com/blog/)
- [Contact Us](https://discriminationandsexualharassmentlawyers.com/contact-us/)

![logo](/app/themes/discriminationandsexualharassmentlawyers/resources/inc/images/derek-smith-law.svg)

### Request Free Consultation

[800-807-2209](tel:800-807-2209)

© 2026 Derek Smith Law Group, PLLC All Rights Reserved. | [Terms & Conditions](https://discriminationandsexualharassmentlawyers.com/terms-disclaimer/) | [Text Messaging Terms](/sms-terms/) | [Site Map](/sitemap/)

[Close](javascript::)

---

Source: https://discriminationandsexualharassmentlawyers.com/sexual-orientation-discrimination-after-zarda/
