# COURT RULES RELIGIOUS SCHOOLS DON’T GET A HALL PASS FOR DISCRIMINATION - Derek Smith Law Group

[Schedule a Callback](/free-consultation/)     [![Derek Smith Law Group](https://discriminationandsexualharassmentlawyers.com/app/themes/discriminationandsexualharassmentlawyers/resources/inc/images/Derek-Smith-Law-PLLC-logo-new.svg)](https://discriminationandsexualharassmentlawyers.com/)   [![Call 800-807-2209](/app/uploads/2024/06/phone-call8.png) Free Consultation 800-807-2209](tel:800-807-2209)

---

[![Employment Discrimination](/app/themes/discriminationandsexualharassmentlawyers/resources/inc/images/cat-icon.svg) Employment Discrimination](https://discriminationandsexualharassmentlawyers.com/category/employment-discrimination/)

# COURT RULES RELIGIOUS SCHOOLS DON’T GET A HALL PASS FOR DISCRIMINATION

[Derek Smith Law Group](https://discriminationandsexualharassmentlawyers.com) / COURT RULES RELIGIOUS SCHOOLS DON’T GET A HALL PASS FOR DISCRIMINATION

- [![Derek Smith](/app/uploads/2015/12/Derek-T.-Smith.png) Derek Smith](https://discriminationandsexualharassmentlawyers.com/author/derek-smith/) March 29, 2017 3 min. read

Share this post[![facebook](/app/themes/discriminationandsexualharassmentlawyers/resources/inc/images/s-facebook.svg)Facebook](https://www.facebook.com/sharer/sharer.php?u=https%3A%2F%2Fdiscriminationandsexualharassmentlawyers.com%2Fcourt-rules-religious-schools-dont-get-a-hall-pass-for-discrimination%2F)[![X](/app/themes/discriminationandsexualharassmentlawyers/resources/inc/images/s-twitter.svg)Twitter](https://twitter.com/intent/tweet?text=COURT%20RULES%20RELIGIOUS%20SCHOOLS%20DON’T%20GET%20A%20HALL%20PASS%20FOR%20DISCRIMINATION&url=https%3A%2F%2Fdiscriminationandsexualharassmentlawyers.com%2Fcourt-rules-religious-schools-dont-get-a-hall-pass-for-discrimination%2F&via=spotblue)[![linkedin](/app/themes/discriminationandsexualharassmentlawyers/resources/inc/images/s-linkedIn.svg)LinkedIn](https://www.linkedin.com/shareArticle?mini=true&url=https%3A%2F%2Fdiscriminationandsexualharassmentlawyers.com%2Fcourt-rules-religious-schools-dont-get-a-hall-pass-for-discrimination%2F&title=COURT%20RULES%20RELIGIOUS%20SCHOOLS%20DON’T%20GET%20A%20HALL%20PASS%20FOR%20DISCRIMINATION)[![pinterest](/app/themes/discriminationandsexualharassmentlawyers/resources/inc/images/s-pinterest.svg)Pinterest](https://pinterest.com/pin/create/button/?url=https%3A%2F%2Fdiscriminationandsexualharassmentlawyers.com%2Fcourt-rules-religious-schools-dont-get-a-hall-pass-for-discrimination%2F&media=&description=COURT%20RULES%20RELIGIOUS%20SCHOOLS%20DON’T%20GET%20A%20HALL%20PASS%20FOR%20DISCRIMINATION)[![email](/app/themes/discriminationandsexualharassmentlawyers/resources/inc/images/s-email.svg)Email](mailto:?subject=I wanted you to see this site&body=Check out this site https%3A%2F%2Fdiscriminationandsexualharassmentlawyers.com%2Fcourt-rules-religious-schools-dont-get-a-hall-pass-for-discrimination%2F)

TABLE OF CONTENTS

- Sexual Harassment Attorney
- New York City, New Jersey and Philadelphia Employment Attorneys

Marry the father of your child, stop living with him or lose your job. These were the options given to Coty Richardson, the former instructor of exercise science at Northwest Christian University. In 2011, Richardson became pregnant with her third child; when Richardson informed her superiors, they went into a frenzy. In an email revealed during an investigation, a school official admitted that they were concerned that once Richardson started to show, students would notice she was pregnant but not married and  would realize that Richardson had sex outside of marriage, a practice against the strict teachings of the Christian University.

Richardson brought a claim of pregnancy and marital status discrimination against the school. The University filed a summary judgement motion based entirely on its First Amendment rights to religious freedom. The motion focused on a “ministerial exception,” which prevents federal courts from intervening in disputes over members of the clergy and some other employees of religious institutions. This exception has been upheld by the Supreme Court as recently of 2012, however, the Court never stated which employees would be covered.

The Honorable Judge Aiken denied the schools motion. Aiken looked at four factors in determining whether Richardson was a member of the clergy, or another employee as defined by the exception, Judge Aiken determined that she was not. First, Richardson is an assistant professor of exercise science, a secular position. Second, in order to hold Richardson’s position, she did not have to take any special religious training. Third, while  Richardson herself is a Christian, there was no evidence that she ever held herself out as a member of the clergy. Further, Judge Aiken admitted that there is some evidence that Richardson did perform some important religious functions in her capacity as a professor, presumably by virtue of her being a teacher at a religious institution. Lastly, outside of being a professor at a religious institution, Richardson never performed any duties normally  associated with a member of the clergy, such as leading prayer or escorting her students to church.

Once it was established that Richardson wasn’t an employee or member of the clergy within the meaning of the ministerial exception, Judge Aiken turned to Richardson’s claims of marital discrimination. The Court found that she had indeed been treated differently because of her marital status. This ruling sent a strong message that discrimination will not be tolerated, even at religious institutions. The Court found that the school was less concerned about its employees having sex outside of marriage, but rather the perception that its employees were having sex outside of marriage, leading to de facto animus against pregnant women.

Pregnancy discrimination is common place in religious institutions. Our skilled attorney’s at the Derek Smith Law Group, PLLC, have years of experience litigating claims based on pregnancy discrimination. Currently, our attorney’s such as Zachery Holzberg , Esq., are working hard on a variety of discrimination claims to protect the rights of their clients. If you feel like you have been discriminated against based on your pregnancy or marital status, please give our skilled attorneys a call, toll-free, at 877-469-5297 for a free consultation about your possible claim.

## Sexual Harassment Attorney

If you have ever experienced sexual harassment in a major male dominated corporation in New York City, Miami, New Jersey, or Philadelphia, contact a [sexual harassment lawyer](https://discriminationandsexualharassmentlawyers.com/employment-law/new-york-city/) in New York City, Miami, New Jersey, or Philadelphia at the Derek Smith Law Group, PLLC. Our sexual harassment lawyers are thoroughly skilled in sexual harassment and the laws that protect employees from enduring the horrendous activity. They also provide the best legal representation in the tri-state area. For more information on sexual harassment, read our [employment law blog](https://discriminationandsexualharassmentlawyers.com/blog/).

### New York City, New Jersey and Philadelphia Employment Attorneys

If you feel you have been the victim of workplace sexual harassment in New York, New Jersey or Philadelphia or if your employment rights have been violated, then you should immediately contact the NYC, NJ, PA sexual harassment lawyers at the employment law firm of DEREK T. SMITH LAW GROUP, PLLC. No one deserves a [hostile work environment](https://discriminationandsexualharassmentlawyers.com/employment-law/sexual-harassment/hostile-work-environment/).

Call today to schedule a FREE sexual harassment legal advice Consultation in NY, NJ & PA with one of our top rated sexual harassment attorneys here at the Derek Smith Law Group you can [reach us online](https://discriminationandsexualharassmentlawyers.com/free-consultation/) or by calling 877-469-5297. Our NYC employment law attorneys handle a variety of cases involving sexual harassment, racial discrimination, and other employment-related claims. We serve clients throughout New York, including Manhattan, Brooklyn, Queens, the Bronx, and Staten Island. We also have offices in New Jersey, Philadelphia, and Miami to serve you.

#### Make Sure Your Lawyers Have the Verdicts To Back Up Their Negotiations – Results Matter!

- [$4.025 Million Jury Verdict Awarded in Employment Discrimination Case](/derek-smith-wins-4-million-jury-verdict-in-disability-discrimination-case/)
- [$2.5 million jury verdict awarded to sexual harassment victim](https://nypost.com/2014/05/06/ex-bartender-wins-2-5m-verdict-in-sex-assault-suit-against-chef/)
- [$2.2 Million Jury Verdict Awarded to Race Discrimination Victim Against Well Known Glassware Company](https://www.google.com/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=&esrc=s&source=web&cd=3&cad=rja&uact=8&ved=0ahUKEwiTlZXH8PbKAhVFbD4KHT43BycQFggoMAI&url=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.nydailynews.com%2Fnew-york%2Fex-truck-driver-wins-2-2m-sexual-racial-harassment-suit-article-1.2452761&usg=AFQjCNH2fhv2y2qffItOaaqDui1TXhVuRg&bvm=bv.114195076,d.dmo)
- [$1.6 Million Jury Verdict Awarded to Sexual Orientation and Religious Discrimination Victim](https://www.artleonardobservations.com/1-6-million-damage-award-upheld-in-new-york-city-human-rights-religionsexual-orientation-case/)
- [Largest NY Verdict In Employment Law for 2012](https://nymag.com/nymag/advertorial/personalinjury/2013/derek-t-smith/).

Free Case Review       Recent Posts

- [Derek Smith Law Group Rebuts Derulo’s “False” Narrative, Asserts Emaza Dilan Gibson’s NY Lawsuit is Active](https://discriminationandsexualharassmentlawyers.com/derek-smith-law-group-rebuts-derulos-false-narrative-asserts-emaza-dilan-gibsons-ny-lawsuit-is-active/) ![date icon](/app/uploads/2015/12/date_icon_d.png) December 17, 2025

- [Derek Smith Law Group PLLC Files Lawsuit Alleging Racial Discrimination and Assault Against Highland Hospital](https://discriminationandsexualharassmentlawyers.com/derek-smith-law-group-pllc-files-lawsuit-alleging-racial-discrimination-and-assault-against-highland-hospital/) ![date icon](/app/uploads/2015/12/date_icon_d.png) November 3, 2025

- [Jason Derulo and Atlantic Records Accused of Sexual Harassment and Retaliation in Lawsuit Filed by Derek Smith Law Group](https://discriminationandsexualharassmentlawyers.com/jason-derulo-and-atlantic-records-accused-of-sexual-harassment/) ![date icon](/app/uploads/2015/12/date_icon_d.png) October 8, 2025

- [Sexual Harassment vs. Sexual Assault: Know the Difference and Protect Your Rights at Work](https://discriminationandsexualharassmentlawyers.com/sexual-harassment-vs-sexual-assault/) ![date icon](/app/uploads/2015/12/date_icon_d.png) August 14, 2025

- [Sexually Harassed or Assaulted by a Billionaire or Multi-Millionaire?](https://discriminationandsexualharassmentlawyers.com/sexual-harassment-sexual-assault-by-billionaires-millionaires/) ![date icon](/app/uploads/2015/12/date_icon_d.png) July 29, 2025

Our Verdicts

### [$15 Million Verdict](https://discriminationandsexualharassmentlawyers.com/verdicts/15-million-verdict-secured-by-derek-smith-law-group-in-child-sexual-abuse-case/)

15 Million Verdict Secured by Derek Smith Law Group in Child Sexual Abuse Case          Last Edited: May 27th, 2025

About Derek Smith

Derek T. Smith, Esq., is the founding attorney of the Derek Smith Law Group, with over 30 years of experience fighting for employee rights. He has secured millions in verdicts and settlements for victims of sexual harassment, workplace discrimination, and retaliation. With offices in New York City, Philadelphia, Miami, and Los Angeles, Derek represents clients nationwide in high-stakes employment and civil rights cases.

[View all posts by Derek Smith](https://discriminationandsexualharassmentlawyers.com/author/derek-smith/) | [Website](https://discriminationandsexualharassmentlawyers.com/)

Related Blog

## If you liked this, you might also like these.

November 18, 2022

### [Are Nannies Protected Against Sexual Harassment at Work?](https://discriminationandsexualharassmentlawyers.com/are-nannies-protected-against-sexual-harassment-at-work/)

- [![Derek Smith](/app/uploads/2015/12/Derek-T.-Smith.png) Derek Smith](https://discriminationandsexualharassmentlawyers.com/author/derek-smith/) 3 min. read

[Find Out More](https://discriminationandsexualharassmentlawyers.com/court-rules-religious-schools-dont-get-a-hall-pass-for-discrimination/)        October 6, 2022

### [7 Employment Discrimination Claims Starting as Microaggressions](https://discriminationandsexualharassmentlawyers.com/7-employment-discrimination-claims-starting-as-microaggressions/)

- [![Derek Smith](/app/uploads/2015/12/Derek-T.-Smith.png) Derek Smith](https://discriminationandsexualharassmentlawyers.com/author/derek-smith/) 5 min. read

[Find Out More](https://discriminationandsexualharassmentlawyers.com/court-rules-religious-schools-dont-get-a-hall-pass-for-discrimination/)        March 2, 2022

### [How Do You Know If You Are Discriminated Against at Work?](https://discriminationandsexualharassmentlawyers.com/how-do-you-know-if-you-are-discriminated-against-at-work/)

- [![Derek Smith](/app/uploads/2015/12/Derek-T.-Smith.png) Derek Smith](https://discriminationandsexualharassmentlawyers.com/author/derek-smith/) 4 min. read

[Find Out More](https://discriminationandsexualharassmentlawyers.com/court-rules-religious-schools-dont-get-a-hall-pass-for-discrimination/)                ![Stand Up Against Workplace Discrimination](https://discriminationandsexualharassmentlawyers.com/app/uploads/2025/05/derek-team1.jpg)

## Stand Up Against Workplace Discrimination

Get a Free Case Evaluation – No Fees Unless We Win for You!

Newsletter

Subscribe for Legal Insights and Updates from Derek Smith Law Group

[mc4wp_form id=14304]    Follow Us On

- [![Facebook - Derek Smith Law Group](/app/themes/discriminationandsexualharassmentlawyers/resources/inc/images/s-facebook.svg)](https://www.facebook.com/New.York.City.Employment.Lawyer)
- [![Twitter - Derek Smith Law Group](/app/themes/discriminationandsexualharassmentlawyers/resources/inc/images/s-twitter.svg)](https://twitter.com/dereksmithlaw)
- [![LinkedIn - Derek Smith Law Group](/app/themes/discriminationandsexualharassmentlawyers/resources/inc/images/s-linkedIn.svg)](https://www.linkedin.com/company/derek-smith-law-group-pllc?trk=extra_biz_viewers_viewed)
- [![Instagram - Derek Smith Law Group](/app/uploads/2015/12/instagram5.png)](https://www.instagram.com/dereksmithlawgroup_/)
- [![Pinterest - Derek Smith Law Group](/app/uploads/2015/12/pinterest.png)](https://www.pinterest.com/derektsmithlawgroup/)
- [![YouTube - Derek Smith Law Group](/app/uploads/2015/12/youtube-symbol.png)](https://www.youtube.com/@dereksmithlawgrouppllc)

Our Office Locations    [New York Office](https://discriminationandsexualharassmentlawyers.com/new-york-city/)   The Nelson Tower,
450 7th Avenue, 30th Floor
New York, 10123   [(212) 587-0760](tel:2125870760)  [Map and Direction](https://maps.app.goo.gl/upBDU5BG2QNkPqSz9)    [New Jersey Office](https://discriminationandsexualharassmentlawyers.com/new-jersey/)   60 Washington Street,
Suite #101B,
Morristown, NJ 07960   [(973) 388-8625](tel:9733888625)  [Map and Direction](https://www.google.com/maps/search/?api=1&query=Derek%20Smith%20Law%20Group%2C%20PLLC%2C%2060%20Washington%20St%20Suite%20101B%2C%20Morristown%2C%20NJ%2007960)    [Philadelphia Office](https://discriminationandsexualharassmentlawyers.com/philadelphia/)   1628 Pine Street
Philadelphia, PA 19103   [(215) 391-4790](tel:2153914790)  [Map and Direction](https://maps.app.goo.gl/YpmK3VLmGniXaijP7)    [Miami Office](https://discriminationandsexualharassmentlawyers.com/miami/)   520 Brickell Key
Dr STE O301
Miami, FL 33131   [(305) 946-1884](tel:3059461884)  [Map and Direction](https://maps.app.goo.gl/Rys6pdrb8tFHbjzn7)    [Los Angeles Office](https://discriminationandsexualharassmentlawyers.com/los-angeles/)   US Bank Tower,
633 West 5th Street, Suite 3250
Los Angeles, CA 90071   [(310) 602-6050](tel:3106026050)  [Map and Direction](https://maps.app.goo.gl/WVNHGwwAXWz2rWQSA)    [San Francisco Office](https://discriminationandsexualharassmentlawyers.com/san-francisco/)   601 Montgomery St.,
Suite 312,
San Francisco, CA 94111   [415-915-4322](tel:4159154322)  [Map and Direction](https://www.google.com/maps/search/?api=1&query=Derek%20Smith%20Law%20Group%2C%20PLLC%2C%20601%20Montgomery%20St%20%23312%2C%20San%20Francisco%2C%20CA%2094111)    [San Diego Office](https://discriminationandsexualharassmentlawyers.com/san-diego/)   350 10th Avenue,
Suite 1000,
San Diego, CA 92101   [800-807-2209](tel:8008072209)  [Map and Direction](https://www.google.com/maps/search/?api=1&query=350%2010th%20Ave%20Suite%201000%2C%20San%20Diego%2C%20CA%2092101)    [Washington DC Office](https://discriminationandsexualharassmentlawyers.com/washington-dc/)   1500 K Street,
2nd Floor,
Washington, DC, 20005   [(202) 938-1794](tel:2029381794)  [Map and Direction](https://www.google.com/maps/search/?api=1&query=1500%20K%20St%20NW%202nd%20Floor%2C%20Washington%2C%20DC%2020005)         We are a *top-rated sexual harassment and employment litigation law firm* with an unmatched record representing survivors.

- [Home](https://discriminationandsexualharassmentlawyers.com/)
- [Firm Overview](https://discriminationandsexualharassmentlawyers.com/firm-overview/)
- [Our Team](https://discriminationandsexualharassmentlawyers.com/attorneys/)
- [Sexual Harassment](https://discriminationandsexualharassmentlawyers.com/employment-law/sexual-harassment/)
- [Employment Discrimination](https://discriminationandsexualharassmentlawyers.com/employment-law/)
- [Other Practice Areas](https://discriminationandsexualharassmentlawyers.com/practice-areas/)
- [Our Verdicts](https://discriminationandsexualharassmentlawyers.com/verdicts/)
- [Testimonials](https://discriminationandsexualharassmentlawyers.com/testimonials/)
- [Blog](https://discriminationandsexualharassmentlawyers.com/blog/)
- [Contact Us](https://discriminationandsexualharassmentlawyers.com/contact-us/)

![logo](/app/themes/discriminationandsexualharassmentlawyers/resources/inc/images/derek-smith-law.svg)

### Request Free Consultation

[800-807-2209](tel:800-807-2209)

© 2026 Derek Smith Law Group, PLLC All Rights Reserved. | [Terms & Conditions](https://discriminationandsexualharassmentlawyers.com/terms-disclaimer/) | [Text Messaging Terms](/sms-terms/) | [Site Map](/sitemap/)

[Close](javascript::)

---

Source: https://discriminationandsexualharassmentlawyers.com/court-rules-religious-schools-dont-get-a-hall-pass-for-discrimination/
